Parables: The Parable of the Vineyard Owner – Matthew 20:1-16
- July 22, 2024
- Pastor
- 0 Comments
Matthew 20:1-16
Let me invite you to take your copy of God’s Word and turn with me to Matthew 20. All of the parables we’ve considered thus far have come to us from Luke’s Gospel, but this one is found in Matthew. In fact, this parable is only found in Matthew’s gospel, and it’s hard for us to accept. I think you’ll see why in a moment.
All of you who have children or grandchildren know that very early children learn the phrase “It’s Not Fair!” They get it. They don’t need to be instructed in it. You don’t have to sit down and show them: “Did you see that? That’s not fair.” You don’t have to do that. They just get it. The portions at the dinner table are too small. Or, if they’re eating vegetables the portions are too big. Later, if they have a curfew, if they have music that they’re not allowed to listen to, if there’s some rule that’s different from their friend’s house, they’ll say, “it’s not fair.” And it’s one of the things that all of us feel; though, as we get older, some of us learn not to say it quite so loudly (more of a mumbling under our breath).
We may feel like our jobs aren’t fair, the pay isn’t fair, our level of taxation isn’t fair, the marriage we’re enduring isn’t fair, or our declining health isn’t fair. Or perhaps you find yourself needing to schedule a service appointment with someone from the telephone company to come out and fix your internet modem because it was hit by lightning, and you’re stuck in the dreaded automated phone directory trying to get your call to an actual living, breathing human that can speak clear English and you think, “This isn’t fair!” Your meal shows up at the table a little less appealing than you’d envisioned and you say, “I cannot believe this. It’s hardly fair.” None of us go through life without thinking about this and saying it often.
Now let me be clear, there are real injustices in the world – don’t want to discount that, don’t want to suggest that we don’t do anything about that, don’t want to say that our laws and judicial systems and standards should not be fair, they should, and there’s a place to lament and cry out against injustice – but what I’m speaking of is an entire way of looking at the world. Some of us, whether we’ve had real experiences of unfairness or not, look at the entire universe through this lens of fairness. And we’re always assessing what we think we deserve. We’re always keenly aware of other people’s successes compared to our supposed failures. We’re always cognizant of whether we’re being recognized or ignored. We see the whole world and experience all of life through these lenses of fairness. That’s how we look at life.
As many of you have noted, recently I’ve had to start wearing glasses to read. Now, I know there’s nothing peculiar about my situation. It’s just the normal process of aging – something known as presbyopia. But some of you have to wear glasses or contact lenses to see anything. If you get out of bed in the middle of the night, you have to put on your glasses or you can’t see where you’re going. When you get up in the morning, you reach over to the nightstand and pick up your glasses because you can’t see without them.
All of us put on some type of lenses whereby we look at the world. None of us simply experience the world, we interpret it. So, you’re not just looking at the world around you, you’re interpreting what’s happening to you and for some of us, it’s only through those glasses of fairness. We’re always sizing up, always calculating, always feeling like we’re owed something by our friends, our family, our church, or even by God.
But there’s another way to look at the world, another way to get up every morning and experience life and that’s by putting on the glasses of grace. When you replace your lenses of fairness with the glasses of grace you wake up most mornings realizing that it’s better than you deserve. And the hard days, well you work to believe that they’re for your good, and when people succeed, you smile. Instead of experiencing life as a series of disappointments where you don’t get what you deserve, you experience life as a gift, and whatever good you have you say that’s God’s grace, and whatever good you see in someone else’s life you say that’s God’s grace. That’s a profoundly different way of viewing the world.
When you wake up each day and you put on the lenses of fairness you will always feel as though you’ve been put in last place when you deserve first. But when you walk through life wearing the glasses of grace then you know the joy of believing that you have been given first place, though you surely deserve what is last. I wonder, “How are we viewing the world?” Have you – husband, wife, parent, grandparent, friend, neighbor, stranger, pastor – only been putting on the lenses of fairness rather than the glasses of grace? How are we looking at the world? That’s what I want us to consider. Let’s see what Jesus has to say about this. Follow along with me as I read Matthew 20:1-16:
1 “For the kingdom of heaven is like a master of a house who went out early in the morning to hire laborers for his vineyard. 2 After agreeing with the laborers for a denarius a day, he sent them into his vineyard. 3 And going out about the third hour he saw others standing idle in the marketplace, 4 and to them he said, ‘You go into the vineyard too, and whatever is right I will give you.’ 5 So they went. Going out again about the sixth hour and the ninth hour, he did the same. 6 And about the eleventh hour he went out and found others standing. And he said to them, ‘Why do you stand here idle all day?’ 7 They said to him, ‘Because no one has hired us.’ He said to them, ‘You go into the vineyard too.’ 8 And when evening came, the owner of the vineyard said to his foreman, ‘Call the laborers and pay them their wages, beginning with the last, up to the first.’ 9 And when those hired about the eleventh hour came, each of them received a denarius. 10 Now when those hired first came, they thought they would receive more, but each of them also received a denarius. 11 And on receiving it they grumbled at the master of the house, 12 saying, ‘These last worked only one hour, and you have made them equal to us who have borne the burden of the day and the scorching heat.’ 13 But he replied to one of them, ‘Friend, I am doing you no wrong. Did you not agree with me for a denarius? 14 Take what belongs to you and go. I choose to give to this last worker as I give to you. 15 Am I not allowed to do what I choose with what belongs to me? Or do you begrudge my generosity?’ 16 So the last will be first, and the first last.”
“Now our Father, once again, we ask for the presence of the Holy Spirit – the Spirit of truth – to teach us through Your written Word. We ask that this word may quicken our souls to a deeper appreciation for Your kindness and Your mercy upon us. For we ask it in Jesus’ name. Amen.”
There’s no need for me to explain the facts of the parable. Right? I mean, we all understand this. We’ve all seen this in some shape or form. Right? A business owner goes down to the unemployment office or the local labor finders location and says, “Hey, hey, I’ve got some work and I’ll pay you minimum wage” (that’s roughly the value of a denarius). Some of those standing in line say, “Sure, I’ll go with you.” He takes them to his business and puts them to work. This takes place at 6:00 a.m. (daybreak), that’s when the Jews started counting the hours. He goes back out at the third hour (9:00 a.m.) and does the same thing, and again at the sixth hour (12:00 p.m.), the ninth hour (3:00 p.m.), and then again at the eleventh hour (5:00 p.m.) – just one hour from quitting time. When the factory whistle blows (at 6:00 p.m.) the business owner calls the foreman in and starts handing out paychecks and he gives all the workers the same pay. Naturally, this upset the first group because they worked longer and harder than the last Yahoos, and so they complained to the business owner. In reply to their complaints, the business owner asks three questions and these questions will reveal a lot about our hearts and a lot about God.
Did You Not Agree With Me For A Denarius?
Verse 13, ‘Friend, I am doing you no wrong. Did you not agree with me for a denarius?’ Let’s be honest. All of us would side with the earliest workers because they were there first. They worked harder. They sweated more. And these slackers rolled in at 5:00 p.m. and didn’t have to endure the non-airconditioned factory floor. They didn’t work for 12 hours. And so, they’re thinking what all of us are thinking: “We’ve been here from sunup to sundown and these loafers got here an hour ago and what gives him the right to give them as much as he gives us?” And you can’t help but put your Bible down and say, “Yeah, what about that, Jesus? That’s not what I would want from my employer.” Jesus does this with the parables. I’ve told you that there’s always this hook, this switcheroo, this detail that captures our attention.
Listen to this illustration from pastor, author, and theologian Kevin DeYoung. He writes:
The food I enjoy the most is pizza. I would be embarrassed to tell you how many times a week I eat pizza. When I was in college and everyone gathered around and wanted to order pizza I always took charge of the ordering – not because I was a good leader but because I knew what would happen and I wanted to make sure that we had enough pizza.
See, I grew up in a godly family, and every Friday night we had pizza from Little Caesar’s. We had four large pizzas for six people because you don’t want to run out of pizza. But it was a great culture shock when I married into my wife’s family. It was one of the first times we were there and my mother-in-law, whom I love, was really trying to serve and be accommodating and we were having pizza. We had my brother-in-law and his wife and kids, me and my wife, and my in-laws, so there were about 8-9-10 of us but only one pizza and it was in the oven. In my wife’s family before you eat pizza you eat salad and some yogurt and waste all the space in your stomach.
So, when I was in college, I took charge because you want to have enough. But I also took charge because you want to make sure you have the right kind – I want pepperoni. And you’d always have a person (generally a young woman) who said, “I don’t want anything. Maybe just a piece.” But you know what; the next time you see her she has three slices of pepperoni on her plate. And I would be so uptight about this, so I wanted to take everyone’s order.
“Ok, so you want two pieces. Hey everybody, she’s a twofer. Got it? Ok, three, and you said you wanted tofu. You’re not going to eat any of this. No pepperoni, ok?” I make sure everyone’s lined up because when the pizza comes, I don’t want the person who only put in one dollar to get my five dollars’ worth. I don’t want the person who only wants broccoli and gluten-free stuff to eat my pepperoni. You can tell I have some issues here, but I wanted to make sure that we got what we paid for. “You paid for one piece of veggie, that’s what you get. I paid five dollars to get a whole pepperoni pizza for myself.” I’m going around and checking because I wanted it to be fair.
We can be like this in the kingdom. We have some blessing police running around: “What’s God doing over there? Do you really deserve that?” The issue is, has God been faithful to you? Has God delivered on the promises He made to you? God is not unfair so long as He gives us what He promised. That’s the point He’s making. “Did I not promise you a denarius? I gave you a denarius. Where’s the unfairness? I gave you exactly what I promised.” But some of us are always looking over someone else’s shoulder.
What has God promised you? Has He promised to give you wisdom? Surely, you can look back on your life and see how He’s answered your prayers for wisdom. Hasn’t God been true to make even the hardest things in your life work for your good? Oh, we need vacations, don’t get me wrong, but when you look back over your life it’s not the vacation to Disney World that refined you, that shaped you, that caused your faith to grow, it was the diagnosis, it was the divorce, it was the layoff and on the other side you say, “God had a plan and a purpose.” What undeserved blessings has God given us? Are you looking at life through the lenses of fairness or the glasses of grace?
Am I Not Allowed To Do What I Choose With What Belongs To Me?
Here’s the second question (verses 14-15), “Take what belongs to you and go. I choose to give to this last worker as I give to you. Am I not allowed to do what I choose with what belongs to me?” You see, the laborers were complaining about their rights. We worked all day and they only worked one hour, yet we didn’t get paid more. Don’t we have a right to our fair share? That’s what the laborers are arguing. But the master sees this business of rights a little differently. He says, “You have a right to receive exactly what I promised you. That’s your right. So, take your paycheck and go. But let’s talk about another ‘right.’ Don’t I have a right to do what I want with my money?” Jesus is making this point: God is in debt to no one. He gives according to His grace. It’s out of His inexhaustible riches that any of us have any good gift. It’s His money, His gifts, His blessing, His talents, His church, His opportunities and He distributes it as He pleases. We’re clay. He’s the potter. He can do what He wants.
Whether you arrive at six in the morning or the eleventh hour it’s the kindness of the master to call you in, to hire you, to promise you and to give you what He’s promised. Remember, this isn’t about your employment. This parable isn’t about working at Home Depot. This parable isn’t about raising the minimum wage. It’s about the kingdom (look at verse 1, “The kingdom of heaven is like…”). The kingdom doesn’t operate according to our labor but according to God’s generosity.
In the Old Testament, the nation of Israel was commonly associated with a vineyard (Isaiah 5 and 27). In Jesus’ day, indeed when He’s teaching this parable, tax collectors and Gentiles are coming into the kingdom, are being grafted into the vine, are becoming a part of the vineyard. And these Jews who had been there since 6:00 in the morning – they had the patriarchs and the law and the traditions and they went through the Exodus and the captivity and all their labors in the heat of the sun and now (at 5:00 p.m.) some Gentiles come wandering in. “And they end up in heaven with us? It’s not fair, I tell you!” That’s why Jesus says, “Doesn’t God have a right to do what He wants with His grace?”
Or Do You Begrudge My Generosity?
And that brings us to the heart of the matter (verse 15), “Or do you begrudge my generosity?” The business owner says, “Let’s get down to brass tacks. This isn’t about a denarius. It’s not about your hard labor in the sun. It’s about your heart. You’re upset because I’m generous.” Are you the type of person who marvels at God’s generosity, or are you the type of person who gets envious of it? You think, “I wouldn’t be so unhappy with what I have, except that I see others having so much more.” This is where social media is a negative influence. If you’re on Facebook, or Instagram, or Twitter, or Tik Tok, or YouTube, or any of the other hundreds of online spaces then it’s just a perpetual temptation to jealousy. Everything that everyone else has or does – you see their jobs, and their vacations, and their money, and their opportunities, and their abilities, and their looks, and their connections. And don’t think that pastors are immune from this. We see colleagues with bigger churches and ministries and platforms, colleagues who are more gifted preachers or teachers, colleagues whose children are following in the ministry, or whatever. There’s always going to be something or someone else out there.
Do you begrudge my generosity? It’s a big vineyard, and it needs a lot of workers, and may the Lord bless as many as He chooses with as many gifts as He pleases. And Jesus concludes with verse 16, “So the last will be first, and the first last.” That’s the point of the three questions. Now, don’t get caught up trying to figure out how that works. See, if you’re like me you think, “Well, if the last become first and the first become last, then didn’t they just switch places and thus the first (who are now last) will be first again, and the last (who are now first) will be last again and how does that cycle stop?” It’s not a math problem. Jesus simply means that the kingdom of heaven is not like the world. It’s inverted. It’s surprising. It’s not first come first serve. It’s not based on seniority. God allows for rolling admissions. And once you’re in the kingdom, the master isn’t keeping track of when you got there or whether you really deserve His eternal blessing (because you don’t).
What’s so great about being last, anyway? Well, it’s this, the last will be first because they know that they’re last. The first will be last because they think, for all the world, that they’re really first. Do you want to make yourself very happy? Go through life saying, “I ought to be in last place. But look at me; I’m here in the middle of the pack. I can’t believe it.” Those sorts of people end up first. Do you want to make yourself and everyone else around you miserable, have this big chip on your shoulder, and walk around as if everyone owes you something because of your history, or your theology, or your obedience, or your parenting, or your achievements, or because of your golf handicap. So let’s do ourselves (and everyone else) a favor and take off the lenses of fairness and put on the glasses of grace.